|
By
Relly Sa'ar, Haaretz
Correspondent
The Tel Aviv
District Court issued a ruling on Wednesday forbidding the state
to deport a Colombian national in a relationship with an Israeli
citizen, a soldier in the Israeli Defense Forces, despite the
fact that his visa has long expired.
The 32-year-old
Colombian is seeking permanent residency in Israel, but the
Interior Ministry had decided to deport the man until a final
decision is reached regarding his status. The ministry's
decision was overridden on Wedensday in a ruling by Judge Uzi
Vogelman.
A 1999 High
Court ruling established that the ministry could not deport
foreign nationals married to Israeli citizens. Wednesday's
ruling extends the previous one, and applies it to common-law
marriages common-law marriages, including same-sex couples.
The new court decision will lead to fundamental changes in the
policy of the Interior Ministry.
In practice, the
Interior Ministry deports foreign nationals illegally staying
in the country while their request for permanent residency is
being considered. The court, however, has established that
such policy "infringes more than is necessary on a couple's
right to normal family life, hence it does not meet the
yardstick of morality expected of such a body."
The couple's petition was submitted by the Association for
Civil Rights in Israel. The decision does not mention the fact
that the couple in question is a same sex couple, but rather
relates to the right of any Israeli and foreigner to live
together in a common-law marriages relationship, without the
state's intervention.
During his term of office as Interior Minister, MK Avraham
Poraz (Shinui) had established a lenient procedure recognizing
the rights of couples unable to marry (such as same-sex
couples) to remain together in-spite of visas' expiry.
The former minister has directed that such couples could
become permanent residents in a gradual process. As the
petition revealed, some officials in the Population Registry,
however, questioned the validity of this directive.
Consequently, the immigration administration refused to grant
the Colombian national an official residency status, on the
pretext that the couple's relationship was not genuine.
The Interior Ministry issued a deportation warrant based on
what it considered as an illegal stay of the Colombian
national, and notified the man he must leave the country
before his request for permanent residency would be
considered.
Judge Uzi Vogelman, however, has ruled that "the harm done in
this instance to the petitioners is particularly disturbing ?
the couple's income consists only of a military salary...
since the petitioner facing deportation cannot legally work in
Israel."
The court severely criticized the Interior Ministry for
concealing its regulations for granting residency status for
foreign nationals in common-law marriages with Israeli
citizens, including same-sex couples.
It was also revealed in court that the ministry withheld the
content of the regulations from the legal system as well.
Quoting the late Supreme Court Justice Haim Cohen, Judge
Vogelman stipulated that "secretive law-making" is "one of the
characteristics of totalitarian regimes, and does not
correspond with the practices of a democracy.
|